Brooklyn's Custom Cake Bakery

Every Cake,
Made to Order.

Designed for You.

Located at 2841 Harway Ave in Brooklyn, Bread Plus Bakery has been crafting custom celebration cakes, designer fondant creations, and artisan pastries since 1920. Every order is built fresh, from scratch, just for you.

Est.
1920
Serving Brooklyn
15K+
Followers
100%
Made to Order
How It Works

We Bake It, We Design It

Bread Plus Bakery is a full-service retail bakery. Custom cakes in every size and style, freshly baked artisan breads daily, pastries, cookies, cannoli, and a full line of savory items.

Celebration Cakes
Sizes for 4 to 100+ guests. American, Red Velvet, Carrot & more.
Designer Cakes
Multi-tier fondant creations, sculpted shapes, and custom themes.
Artisan Breads
Baked fresh daily. Loaves, rolls, stuffed breads, pizza & panini.
Pastries & Sweets
Cannoli, strufoli, seasonal pies, cheesecakes, brownies & cookies.

Start Your Order

Choose Your Order

Five ways to order — all made fresh to order.

Most Popular
01

Celebration Cake

Standard Custom Order

  • Sizes from Small Cake (4 guests) to Full Sheet (100 guests)
  • Choose sponge, moistener, filling & exterior cream
  • Add fruit, decorations, inscription & writing color
  • Live price calculator — see your total as you build
  • Full payment by card required to confirm

Card only · Full payment required

Quick Order
02

Signature Cake

6 Classic Recipes

  • Strawberry Shortcake, Chocolate Mousse, Tiramisu, Cannoli, Oreo & Birthday
  • Crafted with specific fillings & finishes that define each flavor
  • Just pick a size & add your writing — we handle the rest
  • Made the authentic way every time
  • Full payment by card required to confirm

Card only · Full payment required

03

Cheesecake

9 Signature Cheesecakes

  • Plain, Brownie, Marble, Pignoli, Cannoli & more
  • Fresh Strawberry, 7-Layer, 7" & 10" sizes
  • Cheesecake with Preserves — Strawberry, Blueberry, Cherry or Pineapple
  • Fixed prices starting at $26
  • Full payment at time of order

Full payment · Prices from $26

04

Pastry Tray

6-Piece Assorted Tray

  • Large Cannoli, Lobster Tail, Napoleon
  • Tiramisu Pastry, Chocolate Mousse, Eclair
  • Everything freshly made to order
  • Order as many trays as you need
  • Full payment at time of order

$30 per tray · Full payment

05

Designer Cake

Fondant & Custom Creations

  • Multi-tier cakes, sculpted shapes & themed designs
  • Fondant work, edible art & intricate hand decorations
  • Upload inspiration photos or describe your vision
  • Our designer contacts you directly
  • Minimum 20 people

Custom quote · Our designer will contact you

The Process

Simple, Start to Finish

01
Build Your Cake
Pick your size, sponge, fillings, and all the details.
02
We Get to Work
Every cake is baked and decorated fresh to order.
03
Pickup & Enjoy
Pay balance in-store. Walk out with something extraordinary.

Our Order Policy

Full payment confirms and holds your reservation. Cancellations 30+ days before are refundable minus a $45 transaction fee. Cancellations within 14 days of the event receive store credit only.

Find Us

Come In, Say Hello

We're here 7 days a week. Pre-orders must wait on line at pickup.

Address
2841 Harway Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11214
Phone
(718) 373-3700
Email
breadpluscakes
@gmail.com
We Serve
The 5 Boroughs
& Beyond
Instagram Facebook TikTok

Bread Plus Bakery reserves the right to refuse, cancel, or modify any order at our discretion. Prices, availability, and product offerings are subject to change without notice. Submitting an order does not guarantee fulfillment — all orders are subject to confirmation. For short-notice orders, we will contact you to confirm availability. We are not responsible for errors in order details submitted by the customer.

What would you like to order?
Celebration Cake
Custom flavors, fillings & decorations. 4–100 guests.
Signature Cake
6 classic recipes with set fillings & finishes. Quick order.
Cheesecake
9 signature cheesecakes. Fixed prices. From $26.
Pastry Tray
6-piece assorted pastry tray. Cannoli, Napoleon, Tiramisu & more. $30.
Designer Cake
Fondant, multi-tier, sculpted designs. Our designer contacts you.
Build Your Cake
Size
Sponge
Moistener
Filling
Exterior
Extras
Details
Running Total $0

Choose Your Size

Standard cake: 2 layers of cream & 3 layers of sponge.

Cake Style

Please select a size to continue.

Choose Your Sponge

Pick the base cake flavor and style.

Please select a sponge to continue.

Choose Your Moistener

Keeps the sponge fresh and adds flavor.

Please select a moistener to continue.

Choose Your Filling

Premium fillings marked ✦ add to your total.

Please select a filling to continue.

Choose Your Exterior Cream

What goes on the outside of the cake.

Please select an exterior cream to continue.

Add-Ons & Extras

All optional. Prices based on your cake size.

Decorations & Writing

Tell us exactly what you want on the cake.

Choose how you'd like your cake decorated.
Decorate as displayed
We'll decorate it in our classic style.
Tap "No Border" or pick a color. If you tap "No Border", your cake will not have a border.
Tap "No Piping" or pick a color. If you tap "No Piping", your cake will not have piping on the side.
Primary colors only — no metallic.
Primary colors only. No metallic or glitter.
Add a 7×10 inch edible printed image
Email your image to breadpluscakes@gmail.com after ordering.
+$26
Step 1 of 7
Designer Cake Request

Tell Us About Your Cake

Designer cakes start at a minimum of 20 people. For smaller events, our celebration cakes can be customized with an edible image.

Designer cakes start at a minimum of 20 people.
Anything special you want added that isn't in the reference photos?
Optional.
Primary colors only. No metallic or glitter.
If your cake should differ from the photos in any way, describe it here. Otherwise leave blank.
Upload photos of cakes you love. This helps our designer understand your vision.

Tap to upload photos

JPG, PNG · Max 4 photos · Max 10MB each

Add a Cheesecake

Choose Your Cheesecake

All cheesecakes are made fresh to order.

Primary colors only. No metallic or glitter.
Add a Pastry Tray

6-Piece Assorted Pastry Tray

Each tray includes one of each — freshly made to order.

What's Included
Large Cannoli
Lobster Tail
Napoleon
Tiramisu Pastry
Chocolate Mousse
Eclair
Price per tray $30
Add a Signature Cake

Our Signature Cakes

Our signature cakes are crafted with specific fillings and finishes that define their flavor. From Strawberry Shortcake to Cannoli Cake — each one is made the way it's supposed to be. Ordering from this section ensures you're getting the authentic version.

Choose Your Cake

Running Total
$0

Your Items

Review your order, add more items, or proceed to checkout.

Order Total $0
Enter Your Card Details

Secure payment powered by Square. Your card details are never stored on our servers.